
Well that’s what I wanted to be able to tell you.
Tony Robbins once told me (ok – so it was on a tape but hey..) that to be successful, we simply need to find out what successful people [bloggers] do, and do the same.
So let’s find and ask some of the top bloggers what they do..
I started with the top 25 blogs about blogging – http://www.dailyblogtips.com/top-25-blogs-about-blogging/ – and asked everyone the following question:
“If you were to focus right in on the most significant factor in the success of your own blog – what would it be?”
Here are the answers, in alphabetical order. (I really should have put Frank at the top.. sorry man..)
Danny Brown – http://dannybrown.me/ says:
It probably sounds cliche, but I’d say nurturing and appreciating your community. Without your community, a blog is really just a private journal. It doesn’t matter if it’s a personal blog or one with a more business-led approach; the community drives its success, so look after it.
Reply to comments (and not just with pat responses). Highlight great comments (perhaps turn them into follow-up posts). Email your commenters and thank them (Valeria Maltoni does a great job of this).
Encourage interaction; ask what your readers would like to read about.
Invite them to guest post for you to share their ideas with the rest of your readers.
Encourage disagreement; I’ve seen way too many “A-listers” become defensive over a commenter who’s questioned their views. Instead of disagreeing, admit your point of view could be wrong as well, and expand the conversation.I could go on, as community is a very big thing for me. But then we’d be here all day
![]()
Let’s just say a blog without a community is like a Ferrari running on the engine of a Mini – it looks the part but it’s missing out where it counts.
~ Danny – that’s awesome – thanks man.
John Chow – http://www.johnchow.com/ says:
My Wife
Now this was the shortest answer – but it’s important. A supportive relationship and environment can make or break anyone’s success.
~ Thanks for that one John – it’s easy to get too ‘left brained’ about this.
Brian Gardner – http://www.briangardner.com/ says:
I honestly think that consistent posting is important. I’ve probably lost a lot of readers due to the fact that I haven’t written much this year, and think that continuing to keep readers and subscribers engaged is key to running a successful blog.
~ Thanks Brian – much appreciated.
Chris Garret – http://www.chrisg.com/ says:
The number one factor I would say is focusing on your audience, what they want/need/find interesting. This doesn’t mean that you try to please everyone all the time, but you need to have an empathy with your audience and to provide something truly beneficial.
Thanks. Hmm.. Chris – Because there is an audience for every conceivable trend/subject/want/need – how does that connection, that ’synergy’ between you and your audience evolve – where does it come from? i.e. How do you establish your original course or goal, and then successfully navigate your way forward?
Chris sent me a picture:

~ Thanks Chris – that sums it up excellently.
Grant Griffiths – http://blogforprofit.com/ [c'mon man - he's the boss..] says:
The single most important factor is content. But not just any content. You have to provide up to date, relevant content on a regular basis. And the content needs to be written for your human audience and not for the search engines. Basically, if you keep the human search engine happy, the inorganic search engines like Google will follow along.
The key I found to having a successful blog of my own is really tied to my first answer. But, I can expand. One problem I see a lot of new bloggers make is not posting enough. I am a firm believer in the fact a new blogger needs to post to their blog daily for at least 3 months to kick it with the search engines and to get noticed. Not only getting noticed by the search engines, but by visitors and other bloggers. Use your content to answer questions too. As a business especially, we get questions daily from people. What I found was, these were the same questions people were searching for on the internet. By using my blog’s stats, I was able to ascertain from the search inquires to my blog, that those questions needed to be answered. So, I answered them and still do. If you answer the questions humans are looking for, you will move up in the search engines and stay there. And if you answer the questions being asked, you become known as the place to go for those answers. And your traffic become visitors. Your visitors become readers. Your readers become subscribers in one form or another. Which all leads to getting business from your blog.
~ Wow – great answer. Thanks Grant.
Matthew Henrickson – http://blogaboutyourblog.com/ says:
Networking.
Whether it’s with other bloggers or just networking with people who would possibly read your blog. Through Facebook I’ve been able to build an awesome community of 5,000 fans which has increased that particular blog 1000%.
~ That’s interesting – thanks Matt.
Frank Kern – http://masscontrolsite.com/blog/ [I want to be like Frank] says:
It’s to always give really good content. Hands down.
~ Much appreciated mister Kern sir, thanks.
Alex King – http://alexking.org/ says:
Be real, be authentic.
~ Thanks Alex – much appreciated.
Michael Martin – http://www.problogdesign.com/ says:
It’s cliché, but I really would say that writing great content is the number 1 success factor. Back when I started Pro Blog Design, social media meant sharing links on Digg and Stumble, but I never could do that properly (Didn’t seem right to be self-promoting so directly!). The only promotion I did was to write good comments on other blogs. The real work was in the content; I just made sure I was writing detailed posts on topics that other people weren’t covering.
~ Nice – thanks Michael.
Mike Sansone – http://www.converstations.com/ says:
In one sentence, “Write with the Reader in Mind.”
To expand, many blogs are a all-I-know-in-one-long-post types of writing. Most readers won’t want to read that. So trust your reading self, then define which types of readers you’re trying to attract (commenters? folks who will share your stuff on Twitter? etc?) and go read what they are reading to get to know the styles they like best.
Write the stuff you want to write, in the style your reader prefers (bullets? lists? short posts).
Write with the Reader in Mind
~ Awesome Mike – thanks.
Yaro Starak – http://www.entrepreneurs-journey.com/ says:
Paul, To answer your question – I think the essence of a good blog is consistent quality content, but unfortunately that answer often isn’t very helpful.
You have to look at what goes into quality content and so far I see it as two very important ingredients -
- Stories: you need to either be doing things yourself or reporting what other people are doing (telling other people’s stories) that are interesting to a group of people
- A willingness and ability to share stories using interesting mediums, whether that be video, audio or just plain entertaining writing
That’s the key to a successful publication of any format, including a quality blog.
~ Yaro – thank so much man.
Denise Wakeman – http://www.buildabetterblog.com/ says:
The single most important factor contributing to the success of a blog is publishing top quality content consistently and constantly. Fresh content posted a minimum of 3 times per week will attract consistent traffic, new leads, new clients and new opportunities for your business.
~ Thanks Denise – much appreciated.
And thanks again to everyone – you are all busy and I appreciate the time you took to respond.
What Can We Learn From This? – Let’s Summarise the Answers:
- Focus on your audience [audience]
- Provide something beneficial [content]
- Blog within common ground between you and your readers [audience content]
- Content – fresh relevant often regular [content]
- Answer questions [interaction]
- Write great content [content]
- Comment on other blogs [interaction]
- Write unique content [content]
- Work within a supportive environment [environment]
- Write with the reader in mind [audience]
- Understand and write for your audience [audience]
- Top quality content consistently and constantly [content]
- Networking [audience]
- Really good content [content]
- Consistent quality content [content]
- Tell real life stories [audience content]
- Use interesting mediums [content]
- Consistent posting [content]
- Engage readers [audience]
- Nurture and appreciate your readers [audience]
- Reply to comments authentically [interaction]
- Highlight great comments [interaction]
- Email commentors and thank them [interaction]
- Encourage interaction [interaction]
- Invite guest posts [content interaction]
- Encourage disagreement [interaction]
And Then Let’s Group Those As Best We Can:
- Content ************ 12
- Interaction ******** 8
- Audience ******* 7
- Environment/Support * 1
So here we have a list of blog success factors, based on the feedback of people who are successful bloggers:

The next step would be to model those activities. Remember though – the scores are just an indication of the answers, not an indication of importance – they are all important – all being the habits of highly successful bloggers.
My strategy as a blogger would be to put together a content plan based around the summary list. I’d also print off the summary list so I could see it as I write my content.
Check out the category on a Blog Content Plan.
I hope you enjoyed reading the article – I enjoyed writing it.
Normally, that would be a nice article, with a good question, a variety of answers, a useful summary and a next step.
But.. after years of working with successful people, training and qualifying as a life coach, studying success and psychology – there’s a little something it feels important to add..
A long time ago – I asked a few very successful (multi-millionaires and happy) people the same question, within the context of personal success though – not blogging.
The most significant factor affecting the success of a person – not so much the success of what they do, but the success of who they are – is their hidden self image – not their conscious self-image.
It turns out that your mindset - basically your attitude – is the predominant and controlling factor of your success in life.
So even if you have the skill, the time and the opportunity – if your mindset is one of negativity, of lack and limitation, one which sits on top of a poor hidden self image – then you will limit or even sabotage your success as it comes your way. Obstacles will mysteriously appear, resistance will manifest – and you may wonder why things seem to go wrong..
This where the benefit of a coaching program comes in. Not only do you learn the skills and the strategies of successful activities – you also develop your self-image – your confidence – your awareness.
Your self worth is a direct reflection of your hidden self image. You will only allow yourself to earn as much as you think you deserve or are worth. Crazy huh?
So as important as a blog content strategy is – also have a self-development strategy – one which takes you along the path of growth.
- to your success – in all areas of your life,
Paul.









Great post, Paul! As a long-term marketer for both businesses and nonprofits, I definitely appreciate the comments about focusing on your audience. All good marketing starts there. But there were new tips for me, such as being consistent for 3 months to really get noticed.
Your close on the psychological component was absolutely on point and a real add to your research. Thanks for sharing
This was a very helpful post. Of course, these ideas are not new, but it's nice to see them laid out in a somewhat empirical way and validated by those who have made it while blogging.
The only thing I'd say that's missing from the list is that we who aspire to be A-list bloggers actually have to execute upon these ideas. And I'm the first to say I'm guilty of not doing that.
Great information Paul. It's always great to understand lessons learned from wise people. MUCH appreciated! Excellent points from Caryn & Bill, too.
Thanks Caryn, yes persistence crops up repeatedly (no pun intended) as a factor in just about any success. Glad you liked the psychology close.. wasn't sure whether to add that bit! pc
Thanks Bill – appreciated. You're absolutely right – action is what creates results – nothing else
I think there's a saying which goes along the lines of “Successful people are those who are willing to do what unsuccessful people aren't”. “Do” being the operative word..
Thanks Mike – yes, I also think the interaction and commenting adds tangibly to the value of any posting.. cheers, pc.
Paul, thanks for including me in your survey. I am in agreement with all the points from your illustrious bloggers. Clearly there is more than one factor that goes into creating a successful blog and keeping your goals and purpose clear in front of you, can guide you to accomplish all that has been suggested.
Blog on!
Hey there Bill,
Do we actually “aspire” to be “A-list bloggers” though? An A-lister is only relevant to their audience. So it may be that Seth Godin is an A-lister to marketers, but not so useful to gravediggers. Or Perez Hilton to celeb fans, not so much Star Wars geeks (and I'm one).
So it's all relevant. Besides, I've watched as many “A-listers” have become a bit egotistical – if this is the price of popularity, count me out
Some great collective thoughts here, Paul, along with your own excellent insights. The great thing about blogging is that anyone can do it and everything can work – it just depends who you want to reach and what you want to say. Creativity and results are limited only by ourselves.
Hey Denise, thank you for responding to the original question, and also commenting – much appreciated. pc.
Thanks Terrisa, may your blog be a most successful one! pc
Michael – thanks for your own invaluable input – much appreciated. pc
Hey Danny – isn't that the wonderful thing about blogging – there are no absolutes – simply being clear about what we want and holding onto that will usually turn whatever we do into effective action.. Thanks again, Paul.
Wow! Could I have a better forum to shoot my question?
First, great post and great advice… thanks a lot!
I'm a lawyer in Mexico… blogging is not that common down here, except for technology oriented people… even though people search the Internet for answers to their questions. I've been blogging form a while now and I've learned a lot from several of you blogging gurus but, I still feel I haven't built a big audience… I feel most of the traffic I get are unique visitors and the recurring visitors are not commenting that much (I mostly get questions asked – you know – free advice, like this very same comment… hehe).
Any thoughts? Thanks!
Thanks for including me in this blogging project
Matthew
http://blogaboutyourblog.com
Thanks for taking part Matthew – your input was valuable, and much appreciated. Paul.
Hey Jorge, thanks for visiting and commenting so positively.
I'm not familiar with the law industry, however my own thoughts around building an audience would be to first define your audience – for example – is it potential customers, or is it other lawyers? The needs and interests of each would be different – with lawyers likely to discuss and explore issues, and customers more likely to simply want answers.
Through blogging with other lawyers, perhaps your expertise and knowledge would be visible to customers also as you discuss issues with other lawyers and give (anonymous) examples of what works..
Commenting on other blogs, as you are doing with this one, will help build an audience.
Also, check this out, which I came across the other day:
http://www.jigglingtheweb.com/
- all the best,
Paul.
Thanks Paul, I will check out the link you offered.
See, in Mexico, blogging for profit (cool I could use the phrase) is not that common… I mean, there are a lot of blogs, no doubt about it, but I perceive that there's not that much of a following… I think people just find the blogs in Google and stuff… from my GAnalitycs I do not see that many people come back to the blog (except for those that subscribe).
My blog is focused on potential customers, I market myself as a Small Business Lawyer but many of the visits I receive are not from small business owners…. I think I know what my audience is supposed to be but I'm not reaching that much to them. There's work to be done!
Thanks for the tips!
Jorge
Thanks Paul, I will check out the link you offered.
See, in Mexico, blogging for profit (cool I could use the phrase) is not that common… I mean, there are a lot of blogs, no doubt about it, but I perceive that there’s not that much of a following… I think people just find the blogs in Google and stuff… from my GAnalitycs I do not see that many people come back to the blog (except for those that subscribe).
My blog is focused on potential customers, I market myself as a Small Business Lawyer but many of the visits I receive are not from small business owners…. I think I know what my audience is supposed to be but I’m not reaching that much to them. There’s work to be done!
Thanks for the tips!
Jorge